The Best Daggerheart Discussions So Far: Edition 2

We looked at the data. We re-read all the entries. Here are the Discussions that mattered most to you, so far. Part deux.

The Best Daggerheart Discussions So Far: Edition 2

IN THE YEAR SINCE we published our first "best discussions" post, nothing and everything has changed about Daggerheart.

Nothing insofar as it's still the same game it was 12 months ago. It still draws the same praise and ire. People like the duality dice. They're stymied by Fear accumulation. They think combat after T3 is borked. Noted.

But also everything, insofar as there are now thousands and thousands of GMs who can offer thoughtful, concise remedies to what is sometimes a rule and often a ruling. Knowledge, and occasionally wisdom, are now available at the dispensary.

Unsurprisingly, a chunk of Daggerheart conversations are about D&D expats who heard the siren but are still bedevilled by the song. Then there are mechanics. There are always mechanics because systems are tools and tools operate on gears.

Naturally, there are questions about role-playing rather than roll-playing. How can we make the stories work? The characters more dramatic? How DO the theatre kids do it?

And, finally, there are the existential evergreens. Is Daggerheart the best? The worst? Will it stay? Can it stay?

So here they are—the Best Daggerheart Discussions So Far, Edition 2. See if your question or answer are here, and guess my favourite headline.

😈 UNLEARNING D&D

Roll Call

A GM who stress-tested Daggerheart before writing a campaign worried that the Hope/Fear meta-currency was dragging down gameplay. There were too many rolls and a paralyzing amount of resources generated by them. u/Rusty-badger came to the rescue with the oft-repeated advice “stop rolling for everything, that’s not how the game is designed,” but then suggested something even more useful for D&D expats who want to roll the dice: use reaction rolls, but call out in advance that it won’t generate Hope or Fear. Full discussion.

All the Wrong Moves

Another D&D expat found the lack of initiative was allowing noisier players to dominate the scene, and that—oddly—the GM seemed to dominate the turn order. u/GMOddsquirrel got right to the point: “your GM doesn't understand that you're not meant to burn Fear like oil every single combat AND your fellow players need to learn how to share.” (r/dnd GMs raise your hand for every time you found yourself replying “your GM is doing it wrong” to a frustrated player.)

That's Me in the Spotlight

A chaser to those discussions was u/NicoDeGallo’s feedback that a GM should direct the spotlight when it supports the narrative. It’s a lengthy response to another GM who was unsure how to prompt players to engage.

FAFO, Folks

“You're supposed to make suboptimal decisions.” That’s Tavyth, ostensibly responding to a chonky thread about 5e expats struggling with narrative flow, but dialling in on players looking to optimize every decision and tanking the story along the way.

“My Bard COULD just hang around in the back, but in a real battle where his friends are all fighting with him? Why WOULDN'T he cast a spell to help? In the rules of the game you could view it as wasting a turn, but in the STORY you're trying to tell, it's a natural reaction. You are all fighting, and you're still a part of the action whether you act or not. You're supposed to make suboptimal decisions. You're supposed to participate. Don't "Throw" the fight, but you've got to participate, because at the end of the day the battle itself is just a vessel for telling a story in the framework of Daggerheart.”

🔮 MATHEMECHANICS

Convoluted Combat

Did Daggerheart shy too far from theatre-of-the-mind for combat? @FedericoValeri thinks so. A veteran GM who tired of D&D’s convoluted system and hoped DH would require less prep noted that, by keeping the grid and relying on attrition, DH combat lands in the mushy middle: not the propulsive narrative of Powered by the Apocalypse, nor the elegant engine of Draw Steel. His back-and-forth with adversary designer Chris Davidson suggests a future where combat design unwittingly backslides towards the D&D system many abandoned when choosing DH.

Soft Solos

Semi-related, are Adversaries too weak? There’s a growing consensus that Solos need buffing, as discussed in this thread, and one way is through Environments. But while environmental actions are intended to create dynamic encounters, there is cognitive overhead and diminishing returns if a GM has to spin plates for Passives, Actions, and Reactions across additional Adversaries and an Environment. Caveat emptor.

Tuning Fork

I liked this advice on using Fear mid-combat:

“Use Fear as your mid-encounter tuning tool. Too difficult? Use less Fear. Too easy? Use more Fear. Players are constantly rolling with Fear? Use some Spotlights to highlight threats/create stakes.”

It’s from a longer thread about “first game thoughts” that inclues solid back-and-forth about learning the ropes.

The Difficulty Dial

“How do you manage combat?” is an evergreen question with as many answers as there are GMs. But for this OP’s query about making fights harder, Adversary Designer Chris Davidson chimed in with a reply worth adding to your GM screen: “Relentless + momentum. AoE attacks. Restrain, push, and otherwise separate the party. Use environments. Use alternative objectives. More bruisers, fewer standards. More fights, fewer rests.”

Block Head

So much of a GM’s “choose and resolve actions” step in the game is bedevilled by not considering practical “on set” details. For example, a GM was stymied by their Rogue constantly slipping into the middle of an Adversary pack and dealing heavy damage by casting Rain of Blades—only to be asked: “How did he get into the middle of the group without some adversarial re/action?” and “why wouldn’t the Adversary group spread out?” To which we’ll add: slow down, think it through. Act like a director blocking the scene and ask “how?” several times.

Inconsequential or Intentional?

How do you dole out consequences during improvisational combat? That question led to several “don’t overthink it” replies, but I was drawn to Prestigious Emu, who mentioned intent:

“I find that if the players tell me both what they are doing and their intent it makes it much easier to adjudicate the outcome/consequences. Get players used to informing you of their intent - there's a difference between pushing an enemy into a wall and pushing them towards the blade of your ally. Intent matters.”

🎯 EVERYBODY WANTS TO RULE THE WORLD

Torches Interference

An OP planning to nix PC light sources so they could apply Shadowdark’s claustrophobic torch mechanics was met with this thoughtful response:

"Maybe it’s just me, but, “I have a worldbuilding idea, so I’m going to make your Abilities suck a bit,” never feels good. I’d leave the PC’s Abilities alone, but make an Environment effect that fights against any lighting. Like, no matter what light you use—flame or magic—it’s half as bright as normal, and fades over time as the environment “eats” the light. Subtle difference I guess, but, “this place fights against light” feels better to me than, “your Ability fundamentally isn’t as good as it should be.” It also means you don’t need to adjust every specific spell.”

Dissecting Damage

Nate from Tabletop Twisty hits a nerve with his examination of health systems among D&D, Call of Cthulhu, and Daggerheart—preferring Darrington's HP/Armour/Stress system for its nuance and ability to paint a more dramatic picture of how a fight progresses and combatants unravel. Related: Stress out your enemies before a fight.

Disposable Domains

SirStanleyCPanther asks "Are there rules for spell scrolls in Daggerheart? Can a scroll contain a one-use Domain card?"to which ThisIsVictor replies "Sounds like you just created the rules for spell scrolls!" Tidy call-and-response—and great idea.

💰 WHAT'S THE STORY, MORNING GLORY?

Fiat for Framing

The more world building is shared among players and the GM, the more you run into problems of coherence. Over at Walking Hat, Rob Donoghue thinks this is where the GM’s ultimate power resides: not general assertion, but veto power so the unfolding story can be properly framed and editorialized.

What's My Motivation?

“I think people often conflate making a character with a pinned-down backstory, and making a character who's firmly tied into the setting. You can have one without the other.”

That’s cavegirl, reflecting on the confusion players and GMs have around character creation. In her view, your character should be in conversation with the setting, but not necessarily tethered. She goes on:

“I also think that while making a character who's well connected to the setting (with ties to NPCs, motives to act, oppinions about the big issues of the game, etc) is vital, the history of who they were before that I couldn't give two shits about; who they are *now* is what matters.

Or, to phrase it more bluntly: I don't give a shit where your vampire went to school or how they learned auspex; what I want to know is what they think of the current prince and what they intend to do about it.”

Low-Not-No

Semi-related, here’s skyknight responding to a GM wondering if Daggerheart is truly a “no-prep” system where narrative can be a free-for-all: 

“The people who say “plan nothing” are being absurd. You can plan things and probably should like major threats, but the trick is to hold on loosely. Let your players have a choice and a voice, let them go where the story interests them and make interesting things happen where they go. React to what they do, instead of forcing them to go where your narrative demands they go.”

Writing a Wrong

A new GM, worried they might railroad their players with a restrictive story, received sage words from ThisisVictor, who, after noting the GM’s comment “I love worldbuilding, making characters, and, most of all, writing narratives” went on to add “Great news, you’re all set! The trick is that you do the first two by yourself and the third one with the players at the table. World building and making characters is nearly all of my GM prep. But I never ever write a narrative down in advance. I don’t say “and then the players will” because that’s a slippery slope to railroading. The players will surprise you 100% of the time.”

Sweaty Socials

True to our generation, everyone’s anxious about social encounters—even in a game. A good thread evolved on how to manage them. Dancovich reminded the OP to start with narrative rather than mechanics, then provided an example. PrestigiousEmu noted there a tools (plural) for socials—and to use them as needed.

🍄 KNOW THYSELF

Multiverse of Radness

“We could enter a world where Daggerheart core doesn't become the game for everyone but at least one "preset" does.”That’s James Quigley over on Bluesky thinking about how DH’s design is broad enough to afford, essentially, filter bubbles. This resonated given just how different How’s My Driving? plays and feels next to Age of Umbra.

Sallowsad

Vedhar's critique—that Sallowlands is a sad and miserable setting that makes for an unwatchable AP and doesn't do justice to Daggerheart—isn't entirely off, nor is his suggestion that the original CR cast needs to embrace their system with the kind of fun and frolicking adventure that made them famous. While armchair strategist is a Reddit staple that ignores the realities of any given business—it often contains a core truth. For Darrington, that truth is that no other AP troupe will provide the kind of propulsion to Daggerheart as their founders in a long-term, upbeat campaign.

Dramaturgy

Some theatrics for the thirsty: Is Daggerheart actually narrative-forward? (ie. do the system mechanics actually generate story?). Then, a lukewarm hot take: Campaign Frames are misunderstood and/or under-appreciated. Finally, Reaction Roll’s entry in this month’s Betteridge Headline Competition: “did Daggerheart fall off?”